Peer review policy

The Revista de El Colegio de San Luis adheres to a quality standard that requires each manuscript received to undergo a double-blind peer review process conducted by academic experts from outside El Colegio de San Luis. 

The reviewers evaluate the following criteria: 

  1. a) Relevance of the topic.
  2. b) Originality of the approach.
  3. c) Theoretical, methodological or empirical contributions.
  4. d) Logical and analytical rigor.
  5. e) Relevant bibliographic review.
  6. f) Appropriate and relevant use of information sources.
  7. g) Clear and well-structured writing.
  8. h) Limitations.
  9. i)  Others considered relevant.

The decision to accept or reject a manuscript is based on the criteria above and the results of the peer reviews. The outcome of the peer review process for an article may be one of the following:

  1. a) It can be published without modifications. The author is notified and his or her authorization is awaited in order to continue the editorial process.
  2.  
  3. b) It may be published once the indicated modifications have been incorporated. In this case, the author is notified of the suggestions and the modified version is awaited. The Editorial Committee reviews the new version and determines whether to proceed with publication.
  4.  
  5. c) It is definitely not recommended for publication. The author is notified of the reason for rejection.


If the Journal receives one positive review and one negative review, it will request a third review to determine whether the manuscript will proceed through the editorial process. Authors are notified of the result of the arbitration within a period not exceeding four months after the Editorial Committee of the Journal has received them.